Learn how to make delicious gluten free challah bread that everyone will love. Eat this yummy gf bread at the holiday table, or any day!
What makes this gluten free challah recipe special?
Challah bread is a highly enriched bread, made with plenty of oil, egg yolks, and some sugar, too. That's how you get that thin, tender, dark brown crust and bread that stays tender for days—plus the rich aroma of deeply browned bread.
This recipe is unlike many other gluten free challah bread substitute recipes you'll find. It can hold its shape as a true, braided bread without being stiff and dry. It has the most beautiful moist, tender, open crumb.
Most gluten free challah recipes you'll find are made in a molded loaf pan that mimics the shape of braided bread. If you search the web for “gluten free challah bread,” you'll often find recipes that ask you to expect that your bread will be “heavier” or more “dense.”
The texture, flavor, aroma, and crumb of your gluten free bread should be no different from whatever conventional bread you've come to expect. And this gluten fee bread hits all the right notes, so keep those expectations high, where they should be!
Is challah bread gluten free?
No. Traditionally, challah bread is made with wheat flour, along with lots of dairy-free enrichments like egg yolks, oil, and honey or other sugars.
This bread is what you might think of as a challah bread substitute, since it's made wheat-free. But it's a substitute that tastes just as it should—and no one will know that it's made with an all purpose gluten free flour blend.
Challah is similar to another enriched bread, gluten free brioche, but they're not at all the same.
Brioche is a richer, heartier bread than challah—and is best made without butter, so it's pareve (neither milk nor meat, which can't be mixed in kosher meal), and can be served with any holiday meal.
Braiding gluten free challah bread strands into a loaf
You can braid gluten free challah bread in a 3-strand, 4-strand, or even a 6-strand loaf. The braiding technique begins the same way as any braided bread recipe—but the handling of the dough requires some special care.
I've used a 3-strand braid here because it's the simplest (if you can braid a ponytail, you can braid a 3-strand challah!). If the 3 strands side by side (by side) are in places 1, 2, and 3, the braiding process is:
- 1 over 2, and return old 2 to 1 spot;
- 3 over 2, and return old 2 to 3 spot;
- Repeat until you reach the end of the braid.
Do not ever pull on the strands, though. They must not fray. Place them where you want them, overlapping them carefully and with intention.
Of course, if you'd prefer, you can use a challah mold pan and place the unshaped dough into the pan to rise and then bake.
Tips for making the best gluten free challah
Start with room temperature ingredients
Unlike many gluten free yeast bread recipes that call for warm ingredients, to activate the yeast quickly, this recipe calls for ingredients at room temperature. We then let the bread rest in the refrigerator so that the liquids are absorbed into the flour.
Use the right amount of sugar
Sugar in baking isn't just for sweetness. In fact, it's most valuable here in this recipe, and in many others, for tenderizing the bread, and keeping it fresh for longer.
The sugar here feeds the yeast, so it can grow. It also helps aid the browning, and results in that deep brown challah crust.
Refrigerate your gf challah bread dough for easier handling
Refrigerating the raw dough in a tightly sealed container does two things. They both make handling the dough easier.
First, it allows the flours time to absorb the liquid. You don't sacrifice any liquid, which the bread needs for rising and for texture, but the dough is less sticky. Second, refrigerating the dough makes it colder, and that makes it easier to handle.
If you don't have time to refrigerate the dough, you can still work with it. It will just be a bit harder to handle, and more fragile.
Give your gluten free challah bread dough time to rise
Yeast bread dough rises faster in warm (not hot) temperatures closer to 80°F that aren't drafty. It rises more slowly in colder temperatures.
It also must be covered properly as it rises, so the moisture in the dough doesn't evaporate. If the moisture evaporates, the dough will be too stiff and the yeast will not grow properly.
Add an egg wash before baking
An egg wash is just a beaten egg with either water or milk. Here, we're using water to keep it dairy free easily.
After the braided raw dough has risen, we brush the egg wash on top of the braids and all along the perimeter. The egg wash helps the braids brown so beautifully, and keeps the dough from breaking through the surface during its oven rise.
Try to avoid letting the egg wash pool in the space between the braids. We want that portion to rise freely.
How to serve this challah bread substitute
This challah bread is amazing in the center of your Jewish holiday meal. But you don't have to celebrate Jewish holidays to enjoy this gluten free challah!
Sliced thickly, this challah makes rich, eggy, lightly sweet gluten free French toast. You'll find yourself snatching some slices from the loaf just to make sure there are leftovers for gluten free bread pudding, too.
Try toasting a generous slice and topping it with light and fluffy scrambled eggs. Or just a big schmear of cream cheese and a light sprinkling of chives.
Storing and freezing your gluten free braided bread
If you're not planning to serve your bread right away, you can keep it fresh for about 8 hours at room temperature. Just wrap it tightly in plastic, and eliminate as much air as possible.
For any leftover bread, be sure to slice it how you'd like to serve it, wrap it tightly in the same manner, and freeze. Defrost it one slice at a time in the microwave or at room temperature, and refresh in the toaster oven.
I don't recommend freezing raw yeast bread, only baked yeast bread. If the temperature drops too low, you may kill the yeast and waste all that hard work and delicious bread!
Gluten free challah bread ingredient substitutions
Is this gluten free challah bread dairy free?
Yes, this gluten free challah bread is already dairy free. It's made with olive oil in place of butter, and water instead of milk.
If you would like to replace the olive oil, I recommend using vegan butter. Do not use a flavorless oil like canola or vegetable oil, or the flavor will suffer.
Can you make this gluten free challah bread without eggs?
It isn't as easy to replace egg yolks as it is to replace whole eggs. You can try using 3 tablespoons of vegan butter in place of the 3 egg yolks to replace the fat of the yolks.
Can you make vegan gluten free challah?
If you replace the egg yolks with vegan butter successfully, you'll need to replace the honey to have a recipe for gluten free vegan challah bread. In place of honey, try using light corn syrup.
Does it matter which gluten free flour blend you use in this gf challah recipe?
Yes! It matters a lot which gf flour blend you use. And it matters that you add the additional 75 grams of tapioca starch/flour.
I highly recommend that you use Better Batter (or our DIY mock Better Batter style blend) as the all purpose gluten free flour blend. It actually took me years to develop a reliable gluten free challah bread recipe without using our gluten free bread flour, so it could be easy—and dairy free.
Don't use Cup4Cup gluten free flour here, even though it is one of my favorite blends. It's simply too high in starch to produce proper bread that holds its shape as intended (it would make a paler, fluffier and more out of shape loaf)—and browns properly here.
This recipe relies even more than usual on true precision in ingredient selection, and in measurement accuracy. For reliable results like the photos that taste amazing, you must use the flours specified, and you must measure by weight.
How to make gluten free challah bread: an easy recipe
The Best Gluten Free Challah Bread Recipe
Equipment
- Stand mixer with paddle attachment (See Recipe Notes)
Ingredients
- 1 ¾ cups (245 g) all purpose gluten free flour blend (I used Better Batter and recommend it highly here; please click thru for appropriate blends you must choose carefully for results!)
- ¾ teaspoon xanthan gum omit if your blend already contains it
- ⅝ cup (75 g) tapioca starch/flour plus more for sprinkling
- 1 ⅔ teaspoons (5 g) instant yeast (See Recipe Notes)
- ¼ cup (50 g) granulated sugar
- 2 teaspoons (6 g) kosher salt
- ¾ cup (6 fluid ounces) lukewarm water
- 4 tablespoons (56 g) extra virgin olive oil
- 3 (75 g) egg yolks at room temperature
- 2 tablespoons (42 g) honey
- Egg wash 1 large egg, at room temperature, beaten with 1 tablespoon water
- Poppyseeds or sesame seeds for sprinkling (optional)
Instructions
Make the challah bread dough
- In the bowl of a stand mixer fitted with the paddle attachment, place the flour blend, xanthan gum, tapioca starch/flour, instant yeast, and granulated sugar. Whisk to combine well.
- Add the salt, and whisk again to combine.
- Add a bit more than 1/2 cup of the water, olive oil, egg yolks, and honey. Using the paddle attachment, beat vigorously.
- With the mixer running, add as much of the remaining water as necessary for the dough to smooth out. In a warm, humid environment, it may take a bit less than the full 3/4 cup of water.
- The dough mixture will come together in a clump and then smooth out and stick to the sides of the bowl. Keep beating until it begins to look whipped, and the color lightens a bit (about 6 minutes total).
- Transfer the mixture to a lightly oiled bucket or bowl with a very tight-fitting lid. Place the container in the refrigerator, tightly sealed, for at least an hour and up to 2 days.
Shape the braided gf challah
- When you’re ready to bake, turn out the chilled dough onto a surface lightly dusted with tapioca starch/flour. Sprinkle the top lightly with more starch, and divide the dough into 3 equal portions.
- Working with one piece at a time, knead the dough in your clean, dry hands, without adding any additional flour of any kind, pinching any seams that separate.
- Begin working the dough into a cylindrical shape, pinching any gaps together, fanning your hands out toward the edges to lengthen the strand.
- Rolling back and forth, create strands about 15 inches long from end to end that taper slowly from the center to each end, with very tapered ends. Sprinkle each strand lightly with more tapioca flour on the outside of the cylinder to smooth the surface, then set it aside.
- Place the 3 strands on a lightly floured surface parallel to one another and about 5 inches apart from one another. Gather the tapered ends on one side together, pinch them securely and tuck the very end under the knot.
- Plait the 3 strands as you would any 3-strand braid. Do not pull the strands, as they’ll fray. Just place them on top of one another as you work toward from one end to the other.
- Beginning as close as possible to the bound end, place one outside strand across the center strand, exchanging the center for the outside strand you just moved to the center.
- Repeat with the other outside strand and center strand. Repeat the process, alternating one side and then the other until you reach the end. Tuck the end under as you did the other side.
- Placing your hands carefully under each side of the braided loaf, carefully lift the braid onto a lined baking sheet. Press the finished braid gently on each ends toward center to shorten the length a bit.
- Sprinkle the top of the braid lightly with more tapioca starch and brush off excess from the valleys between braids.
Let the bread rise.
- Cover the braid securely with plastic wrap, and place the loaf in a warm, draft-free location. Allow the loaf to rise until it’s at least 150% its original size (anywhere from 45 minutes to hours).
- If any of the tops of the strands begin to separate from one another as the dough rises, try to smooth and pinch them closed. When the dough is nearing the end of its rise, preheat your oven to 350°F.
Bake the bread.
- Uncover the risen bread and brush the tops and sides of the braids very generously with the egg wash. Avoid letting the egg wash pool in between the braids. Sprinkle the top evenly with the optional seeds.
- Place the baking sheet in the center of the preheated oven. Bake for 30 minutes, rotate the baking sheet 180° and reduce the oven temperature to 325°F.
- Continue to bake for about 15 minutes, or until the bread bounces back when pressed on a center braid and the internal temperature is at least 190°F on an instant read thermometer.
- Remove the bread from the oven and allow it to cool on the baking sheet for at least 20 minutes before transferring to a wire rack too cool completely. Slice and serve.
Notes
The Best Gluten Free Challah Bread Recipe
Equipment
- Stand mixer with paddle attachment (See Recipe Notes)
Ingredients
- 1 ¾ cups (245 g) all purpose gluten free flour blend (I used Better Batter and recommend it highly here; please click thru for appropriate blends you must choose carefully for results!)
- ¾ teaspoon xanthan gum omit if your blend already contains it
- ⅝ cup (75 g) tapioca starch/flour plus more for sprinkling
- 1 ⅔ teaspoons (5 g) instant yeast (See Recipe Notes)
- ¼ cup (50 g) granulated sugar
- 2 teaspoons (6 g) kosher salt
- ¾ cup (6 fluid ounces) lukewarm water
- 4 tablespoons (56 g) extra virgin olive oil
- 3 (75 g) egg yolks at room temperature
- 2 tablespoons (42 g) honey
- Egg wash 1 large egg, at room temperature, beaten with 1 tablespoon water
- Poppyseeds or sesame seeds for sprinkling (optional)
Instructions
Make the challah bread dough
- In the bowl of a stand mixer fitted with the paddle attachment, place the flour blend, xanthan gum, tapioca starch/flour, instant yeast, and granulated sugar. Whisk to combine well.
- Add the salt, and whisk again to combine.
- Add a bit more than 1/2 cup of the water, olive oil, egg yolks, and honey. Using the paddle attachment, beat vigorously.
- With the mixer running, add as much of the remaining water as necessary for the dough to smooth out. In a warm, humid environment, it may take a bit less than the full 3/4 cup of water.
- The dough mixture will come together in a clump and then smooth out and stick to the sides of the bowl. Keep beating until it begins to look whipped, and the color lightens a bit (about 6 minutes total).
- Transfer the mixture to a lightly oiled bucket or bowl with a very tight-fitting lid. Place the container in the refrigerator, tightly sealed, for at least an hour and up to 2 days.
Shape the braided gf challah
- When you’re ready to bake, turn out the chilled dough onto a surface lightly dusted with tapioca starch/flour. Sprinkle the top lightly with more starch, and divide the dough into 3 equal portions.
- Working with one piece at a time, knead the dough in your clean, dry hands, without adding any additional flour of any kind, pinching any seams that separate.
- Begin working the dough into a cylindrical shape, pinching any gaps together, fanning your hands out toward the edges to lengthen the strand.
- Rolling back and forth, create strands about 15 inches long from end to end that taper slowly from the center to each end, with very tapered ends. Sprinkle each strand lightly with more tapioca flour on the outside of the cylinder to smooth the surface, then set it aside.
- Place the 3 strands on a lightly floured surface parallel to one another and about 5 inches apart from one another. Gather the tapered ends on one side together, pinch them securely and tuck the very end under the knot.
- Plait the 3 strands as you would any 3-strand braid. Do not pull the strands, as they’ll fray. Just place them on top of one another as you work toward from one end to the other.
- Beginning as close as possible to the bound end, place one outside strand across the center strand, exchanging the center for the outside strand you just moved to the center.
- Repeat with the other outside strand and center strand. Repeat the process, alternating one side and then the other until you reach the end. Tuck the end under as you did the other side.
- Placing your hands carefully under each side of the braided loaf, carefully lift the braid onto a lined baking sheet. Press the finished braid gently on each ends toward center to shorten the length a bit.
- Sprinkle the top of the braid lightly with more tapioca starch and brush off excess from the valleys between braids.
Let the bread rise.
- Cover the braid securely with plastic wrap, and place the loaf in a warm, draft-free location. Allow the loaf to rise until it’s at least 150% its original size (anywhere from 45 minutes to hours).
- If any of the tops of the strands begin to separate from one another as the dough rises, try to smooth and pinch them closed. When the dough is nearing the end of its rise, preheat your oven to 350°F.
Bake the bread.
- Uncover the risen bread and brush the tops and sides of the braids very generously with the egg wash. Avoid letting the egg wash pool in between the braids. Sprinkle the top evenly with the optional seeds.
- Place the baking sheet in the center of the preheated oven. Bake for 30 minutes, rotate the baking sheet 180° and reduce the oven temperature to 325°F.
- Continue to bake for about 15 minutes, or until the bread bounces back when pressed on a center braid and the internal temperature is at least 190°F on an instant read thermometer.
- Remove the bread from the oven and allow it to cool on the baking sheet for at least 20 minutes before transferring to a wire rack too cool completely. Slice and serve.
Sol says
Thanks for this recipe! I substitute potatoe flour for quinoa flour and regular sugar for coconut sugar but the result was perfect. I’ve also used traditional dry yeast ( let it rise with warm water and sugar) baked at 350 for 20-25 minutes as I did mini rolls instead of a big challah.
Kira says
Hey Nicole! Have you ever tried to make this recipe with bobs red mill one to one gf flour!?
Nicole Hunn says
You cannot make any of my recipes successfully, especially yeast bread, with any of the Bob’s Red Mill flour blends. Please click through to full information as instructed in the recipe. It says: “I used Better Batter and recommend it highly here; please click thru for appropriate blends you must choose carefully for results!”
Nicole says
Hello, I made this and the flavour was great but I had trouble with the dough rising. Out of curiosity, why do you not use your gluten free bread flour for this recipe? Would that perhaps help my bread to rise? Thanks!
Nicole Hunn says
Nicole, the bread flour is a very particular blend that requires a completely different balance of ingredients. If you use it in recipes that don’t call for it, they will not turn out. This recipe is formulated to be made with an all purpose gluten free flour blend like Better Batter. If you used a different blend other than one of my recommended ones, the recipe won’t turn out either. Please see this post for general tips on making gluten free bread, including getting it to rise.
Miriam says
This recipe is fantastic. I recently made a new friend who can’t have gluten and naively I told her I’d make gluten-free challah for our Shabbat dinner. She seemed very skeptical as did literally everyone else I spoke to about this venture. I read through this recipe and since I don’t live in the US and lots of items aren’t available here (like the better batter blend) I just bought all the ingredients to make it myself. I followed the recipe to the letter and while my dough didn’t come out QUITE as beautiful as Nicole’s (I used a knead blade in my food processor – no stand mixer!) the challah itself was braidable, and looked/tasted pretty close to the usual challah I’d make. My dough was a little looser than Nicole’s looked, after the refrigeration step, so I just used more tapioca flour to keep it together and smoothed over any frays in the braid with my fingers – it honestly came out totally fine despite those challenges. My new friend seemed very surprised by how well it turned out. To anyone attempting this I would recommend following every step and ingredient exactly.Thank you for this recipe!
Nicole Hunn says
That’s really so lovely of you to do for your friend, Miriam! I’m so glad you were willing to buy the component flours to make your own mock Better Batter blend. It’s really worth it!
Kristie Ruth says
Wondering if this could be made with an egg substitute at all? We cannot do gluten, dairy or eggs in our house.
Nicole Hunn says
Please see the substitutions section of the blog post, Kristie.
Sara says
Which better batter flour did you use? I saw a few different ones on their site and wanted to make sure I purchased the right one. Thank you!
Nicole Hunn says
I only ever use their “classic blend,” I believe they now call it, Sara. It was the only one until they came out with their “rice-free” blend, which I tested quite a bit and just don’t care for at all. Hope that helps!
Gracia Tilley says
My dough was in the refrigerator 24 hours and it did not rise at all. I did use rapid rise yeast.
Any suggestions
Nicole Hunn says
Without any details, I’m afraid I can’t know where you deviated from the recipe as written, Gracia. Here are the things I always suggest you check when your yeast bread dough isn’t rising in the refrigerator: 1. Did you measure by weight, not volume (if you undermeasure water or overmeasure flour, your hydration ratio will be off and your dough won’t rise)? 2. Did you use the ingredients as directed, particularly the flour blend? You can’t use just any gf flour blend. 3. Did you have your dough rising in a proofing bucket with a tight-fitting lid? If not, your dough is drying out as it’s sitting in the refrigerator, which will prevent rising.
Jen says
I measured EVERYTHING by weight and used the better batter flour blend and it was a more like a pancake batter. Didn’t rise at all. I’m not sure what I’m doing wrong. I alot of bread recipes I try never turns out right with your weight measurements. I always end up needing to add more flour
Nicole Hunn says
Everyone says that they “followed the recipe to a T” but it’s rarely the case, in ways you just don’t realize are important, but are.
Here are some considerations and questions to ask yourself as you attempt to figure out where you deviated from the recipe as written:
Did you make ingredient substitutions? You mentioned that you used Better Batter’s flour blend. Did you use the “classic blend,” or did you use the newer artisan blend, which will not work in my recipes.
With respect to yeast bread, did you allow the dough to rise long enough, and was your dough covered properly? Overproofing is a function of rising too much, not too long. It can take a long time for yeast bread to rise properly in a cool, dry environment, especially. A lack of rise with a super wet bread likely means that the yeast wasn’t fresh, since the main reason that yeast bread dough doesn’t rise at all is lack of moisture. Clearly, that’s not your issue. I’m afraid that’s all I can do to help you figure out where you went wrong, as I’m not there with you.
Wendy says
Nicole,
Thank you for taking the time to perfect this recipe! We have missed homemade challah since we had a Celiac diagnosis in our home! I have made this twice and am really happy with the results. I do struggle a bit with the quantity vs. measurements of some ingredients. For example, 3 egg yolks weigh a lot less than 75 grams for me…even 4 yolks were not 75 grams. Same with honey. Should I follow the weights or the quantities/TBS? The second time a made this, the dough was wetter and harder to handle so I am wondering if my ingredient measures are off.
Thanks again,
Wendy
Nicole Hunn says
You should always go by the weight measurements, Wendy, since volume measurements are fraught with human error and non-standardized, so they are inherently unreliable. The corresponding volume measurements are merely there because otherwise readers get very angry at their absence. There is nothing to be gained from measuring by volume and then checking the weight.
Alli says
Thank you so much for this wonderful recipe. It turned out amazing! My family doesn’t eat gluten free but we have many friends who avoid it or have celiac disease. It makes it hard to know what to serve when they come over. I now have a solid go to. I couldn’t get ahold of the blend you suggested but found DIVIDED SUNSET gf flour at Walmart that had the same ingredient list as your blend. It was missing pure powder pectin. I added 1tsp ground chia seeds instead. It tasted just like bread. My husband and kids raved “one of the best breads I have ever made” Our GF meals will never be the same again !! Thank you
Nicole Hunn says
I’ve never heard of that blend before, Alli, but I’m so glad you were able to find something that worked so well for you. And that’s so kind of you to go out of your way like that for your gluten free friends. People like you make it possible to eat gluten free out of the house!
Robyn Rypp says
Hi Nicole, I love your recipes!! Second time making this Chalksh and same thing happened- followed recipe very specific, all was good through the rising and putting in oven, but during the baking the braid separated and areas in the middle created valleys where it separated. It looked perfect going into the oven. Can you help me trouble shoot? Thanks.
Nicole Hunn says
It sounds like your issues are in shaping, Robyn. Just reread the portion of the recipe and the post where I discuss how to braid it without putting any tension on the strands. The egg wash is also very useful in sealing the rise in the oven, which I also discuss. It takes a bit of practice, but it sounds like you’re well on your way!
Robyn says
Thanks Nicole! Will work on that tension!
Dan says
I was so excited bout this recipe. Unfortunately after I took the dough out of the fridge after chilling for over an hour, the dough was extremely sticky and I was completely unable to knead it. Unfortunately this was a waste of time, energy and supplies for me.
Nicole Hunn says
Dan, this recipe works when made as written, but it must be made precisely with the ingredients specified, especially including the flour blend and additional tapioca starch, all measured by weight. It took me years to arrive at a reliable recipe, but it must be followed precisely.
Katie Davis says
I am SO appreciative of your help!
I did weigh the water to 6oz, but I wonder if it’s the salt? You call for 2 teaspoons (6 g) kosher salt and I measured to 6g but 2 teaspoons of salt weighs 12g? Do I have that wrong?
PS First, I proofed the sticky dough for 2 hours and it did rise, but other than the outside, it was still super sticky. I dumped it on a baking sheet, brushed with the egg wash and baked it up. It was lopsided, gorgeous color and tasted great! Second, I am going to try it again and this time I weighed each ingredient and took a photo of every thing I had to measure, just to make sure I’m doing it correctly! So we’ll see! Thank you again (would love to know about that salt question!)
PPS Your privacy policy box isn’t showing an X or check mark…fyi.
Nicole Hunn says
Katie, if you used a fine grain salt, like table salt, it will be denser per volume. But when you’re measuring by weight, volume is irrelevant. If you’ve been using volume in any way where weight is directed, that’s a mistake. I’m afraid I just don’t know where your process took a turn.
Katie Davis says
Thank you for your speedy response, Nicole! I am sure this is my fault! But I can’t figure out what I did wrong. I watched your video prior to making it, I used Better Batter GF flour, and I weighed everything listed by weight in grams. I didn’t add xanthum bc my understanding is that Better Batter already has it. I used Tapioca flour, not Tapioca starch. It’s been in the fridge for about 12 hours now and is sticky to the touch. Could the tapioca flour v. starch be the problem? Thanks in advance!
Nicole Hunn says
Hi, Katie, Tapioca starch and tapioca flour are the same thing, and you did the right thing not adding more xanthan gum. The only other things I can think of is you over-measured your water? After sitting in a sealed container in the refrigerator, it might have absorbed enough of the moisture to be properly workable. I’m still optimistic! Try not to add too much flour during shaping, and add tapioca starch, not more Better Batter, as instructed, and I think you’ll be fine. :)
Katie Davis says
One more thing – I just mixed everything – triple checking that it’s all weighed out – my photos came in handy for that. I have a video of how soupy it is if you want to see it. I am baffled. What could I be doing wrong?
Katie Davis says
This sounds amazing, thank you so much! I’m going to a shabbat dinner on friday and decided to try this. The dough is now in the fridge but was it supposed to be kind of goopy? Almost pourable and gooey as it goes from the mixer bowl to the lightly greased bowl? Thanks in advance!
Nicole Hunn says
No, it’s not, Katie. Please see the photos and the video for a closer look. It sounds like you either used a gluten free flour blend that isn’t one of my recommended blends, or measured by volume, not weight. Both of those are essential for success, as described in more detail in the post.
Katie Davis says
I baked my goo and though it wasn’t braided, it tasted great. I will try this again, and hope I get it right! Thanks for the recipe.
Nicole Hunn says
Try measuring the water by weight, too, Katie. 1 fluid ounce of water = 1 weighted ounce. Are you beating the dough well enough, in a stand mixer fitted with the paddle attachment? That could also be part of the issue.
Milvi says
I gave it a try and it turned out perfectly!! It tastes as I remember it from my days before GF. I have been hoping for this recipe for a long time. When working with the dough, I wore nitrile gloves and kept them dusted with tapioca starch. Stickiness was minimal. I am thinking of forming the dough into knotted buns for a variation.
Nicole Hunn says
I’m so glad you were willing to give it a try, Milvi! I worked on it for so many years because nothing less than authentic would do. The smell was so recognizable that I knew after it had only spent like 5 minutes in the oven. I’d love to hear how it goes with knotted buns, if you decide to try!
A. Littles says
This was a hit! Delicious! Thank you!
Nicole Hunn says
I’m so happy to hear that! Thank you for letting me know. :)
Izzy says
You state in the recipe to let the dough rise 150%. Is it until doubled or tripled the volume?
Nicole Hunn says
Izzy, 150% rise means that it’s one and a half times as big as it was before it started rising. Since you haven’t made the recipe yet, I hope you’ll consider reserving your star rating until you have. A 3-star rating like that really affects things quite a lot.
George G says
The dough in the proofing bucket looks smooth and organized. Mine is not. It’s sticky and disorganized. Do you shape it before you put it in the bucket to rest?
Nicole Hunn says
I just shook it from side to side for the photo, George. It doesn’t matter what it looks like at that stage at all.
George G says
I tried this recipe once before and it was so sticky when it came out of the bucket I couldn’t do anything with it. It didn’t look anything like what you start with in the video when you cut it into three pieces.
Nicole Hunn says
George, I know you often make substitutions, so I’d look there first. This recipe has been well-tested and works when made as written, and handled as written.
Katie says
This looks scrumptious! Could this recipe be used to make some of the fancy braided breads like we see on the Great British Baking Show? For example, adding some sun-dried tomatoes and then brushed with pesto with, or sprinkled with cinnamon + sugar for a special bread on holidays?
Nicole Hunn says
Hi, Katie, I think it could! I don’t like the idea of adding anything like sundried tomatoes that will cause interruptions in the dough as it is shaped and rises. But you could even replace a tablespoon or so of the oil with a well-blended pesto and then brush the top with pesto after the egg wash (you really really need the egg wash to contain the tops of the braids during baking). And sprinkling with cinnamon and sugar is a no-brainer. Right on top of the egg wash. That would be amazing. Enjoy it!
Marian Lund says
Looks just wonderful. Can’t wait to make it. Could I use less sugar? I hate sandwich bread that tastes sweet. Thanks.
Nicole Hunn says
I discuss the sugar in the post, Marian. You need all of it.
Holly says
Hi Nicole, WOW! What a beautiful loaf of bread!
I do not want to disrespect your recipe in any way because I know part of the beauty of this loaf is the aesthetics of the braiding. That being said I suck horribly at anything detailed and somewhat ‘fussy’. I always end up with something that looks akin to an alien or a gag gift!
So here goes…can I possibly make this loaf without braiding it and form it like a regular loaf?
Nicole Hunn says
Hi, Holly, I totally understand that you are reluctant to try braiding this recipe as directed. But I wouldn’t bake this in a loaf without braiding it, no. Just make our recipe for gluten free brioche instead!
Leeba Schneck says
Hi Nicole
There is absolutely no reason you should know about this fact but unfortunately many Jewish people are unaware of this as well. In order for a person of Jewish faith to eat challah with a blessing, the dough would need to have at least 51% of one of the following flours – wheat, rye, barley, spelt or oats. Since oats are the only flour that can qualify as gluten free, that is the only acceptable alternative for those who want to be able to “qualify” eating this on the Jewish Holidays. Oats are not an easy ingredient to use in bread making. It doesn’t taste so great and it’s pretty crumbly. I found someone who makes sourdough oat rolls which are the best I’ve ever tasted. I’d love to get her recipe but am waiting a bit before asking. Obviously, there are some “GF people” who can’t tolerate oats either so they can’t eat this. I make all kinds of challah for my husband – whole wheat/white/ water challah etc. I miss it. But your recipes Nicole are really terrific and your step by step videos are wonderful. And your substitution options are so welcome!
Nicole Hunn says
Leeba, it’s nearly impossible to create a gluten free challah recipe that tastes authentic, and is also dairy free. I’ve worked on this recipe for 2 years (literally). I’m sorry that you can’t use it!
Susan miller says
Do you have a source for the better than GFbatter flour for a smaller
Amount for this challah recipe.
The ones I have seen are like 27$
I want to have success , but can’t find flour in smaller quantities.
I have King Arthur gf and bob’s red mill gf flour.
You don’t seem to reccomend those .
Nicole Hunn says
No, Susan, I don’t recommend those. I’m not sure what you’re referring to that’s $27, or for what quantity, but please see my all purpose gluten free flour blends page for the information I can provide.
Heather says
The 5-lb Better Batter flour is $27 at Walmart and $28 on Amazon. It’s very expensive. Is there a significant difference between all of the gf flours like King Arthur, Pillsbury, and the flour blends you recommend? Would it be better to make a flour blend instead?
Nicole Hunn says
Yes, there is a very significant difference. The best price for Better Batter is in larger quantities, which you can purchase on their website, betterbatter.org. I’d recommend you buy there. You can of course also blend your own.
Liz Pelletier says
If I want bake this the same day, can I let the dough rise at room temp for a couple of hours? Or possibly, until doubled?
Nicole Hunn says
No, you shouldn’t let it rises until doubled, Liz. Only my bread recipes made with gluten free bread flour, which are almost exclusively in my “Bakes Bread” cookbook, are capable of rising until doubled. Please follow the recipe instructions, which instruct you to let it rest in the refrigerator for at least an hour before shaping. It should not double outside the oven.
Karen Utley says
I have the dough in the fridge as I am writing this but I am not clear on how long each of the strands should be before braiding. I don’t want a long skinny loaf or a short one either.
Thanks!
Nicole Hunn says
Hi, Karen, you’re 100% right. I’m so sorry that’s my omission. I added the info now, but it’s about 15 inches long from end to end for each strand. You’re going to love it!