These thin and crispy gluten free chocolate wafer cookies are rich and chocolatey and perfect for making all sorts of no-bake warm weather treats, from icebox cakes to cookie crusts. Stock up for summer!
Why you need chocolate wafer cookies
Remember those Nabisco chocolate wafer cookies that come in those narrow packages? These crispy, crunchy chocolate cookies are just like those, but of course, they’re gluten free. And they are perfect for doing some very important things, especially in the summertime.
When you see blunt edges on cutout cookies, that means that they really haven’t spread or risen much during baking. They have a way different texture than soft & chewy chocolate cookies, which are more cakey. Those give when you bite into them, which makes them perfect for an ice cream sandwich.
These crunchy cookies make excellent cookie crumbs when crushed. Plus, they’re lovely for icebox cakes of all kinds. I know that you can’t really call something “no bake” when you had to bake cookies first to make it. But hear me out!
I’ve searched high and low, and I simply can’t find any simple Nabisco-style gluten free chocolate wafer cookies for sale. You can find packaged GF graham crackers (even though mine are better), and even crispy chocolate chip cookies.
But the simple, noble chocolate wafer must be baked. But they keep for weeks on the kitchen counter when stored in a sealed glass container, or for months in the freezer.
Tips for rolling and cutting out cookie dough
Drop cookies are portioned with a spoon or ice cream scoop and dropped onto a baking sheet. They’re a great place to start out baking.
Cut-out cookies like these chocolate wafer cookies are formed by rolling out the dough with a rolling pin and then using a cookie cutter or knife to cut out shapes for baking. I know that some of you consider that process a “page turner” in a cookbook. You see that the dough has to be rolled out, and you’re on to the next page.
But rolling out cookie dough before cutting it into shapes has so many benefits! And I promise it’s super easy, especially if you know my tips and tricks.
You can see me use these tricks in the how-to video in this post. Plus, an extended version of these tips is on page 28 of Gluten Free Classic Snacks, in case you want a deeper dive. 🏊🏻 On to the tips…
Tip #1. Feel the dough with your hands. Rolling the dough into an even layer tends to be the most intimidating part. The secret is in how it feels, much more than how it looks.
Your eyes can’t really compare the thickness of the cookie dough from one spot to another. But your hands passed over the top of the dough will know in an instant if one spot is too thick, another too thin.
Tip #2. Use the right paper. If the instructions in a recipe tell you to roll out the dough between two pieces of unbleached parchment paper (like they do in this recipe!), definitely do it!
Bleached parchment paper is thick and stiff, so it’s not very flexible. Plastic wrap is guaranteed to wrinkle, which will leave a million little wrinkles in your rolled-out dough. Unbleached parchment paper, the brown kind, is absolutely perfect for this task!
Tip #3. Use a light touch. If you find that you’re rolling lots of creases and wrinkles into the dough, apply less pressure with the rolling pin and pass over those spots again. It’s rolling pin. Not a pressing pin.
Tip #4. Chill it. If the dough seems to difficult to cut cleanly, place it, still in the parchment paper, on a cutting board and chill it in the refrigerator or freezer for a few minutes. It’ll firm up enough to cut.
Tip #5. Peel away. After cutting out your shapes, peel the surrounding dough away from the shapes, and then peel the paper away from under each cut-out shape. It keeps the cut-out from stretching or breaking during the transfer.
I plan to no-bake with these cookies all summer long, and I’d hate for you to be left out! Watch the how-to video, read the tips, and then get your ingredients ready.
Speaking of ingredients, let’s talk about what to do if you have other dietary concerns beyond just gluten free…
Ingredients and substitutions
Dairy-free: Good news! I’ve successfully made these cookies dairy free, and they were absolutely just as good in taste and texture as the original recipe. My favorite substitute for unsalted butter is Melt brand VeganButter. Be sure it’s at room temperature before you use it in the recipe.
If you can’t find Melt brand, I’d try using half nonhydrogenated vegetable shortening (I really like Spectrum brand) and half Earth Balance buttery sticks. If you use all Earth Balance, the cookies will not hold their shape, as Earth Balance has a ton of moisture. And all shortening will probably make for cookies that are too dry.
Egg-free: There’s only one egg in this recipe, so it’s a pretty good candidate for making it with a “chia egg,” which is just 1 tablespoon of ground white chia seeds mixed with 1 tablespoon lukewarm water and allowed to gel. I haven’t tried it, though, so you’ll have to experiment!
Cocoa powder: Since these are chocolate wafer cookies, you can’t make them without cocoa powder. But if you don’t have Dutch-processed cocoa powder, you can use natural cocoa powder. Just add 1/8 teaspoon baking soda to the dry ingredients and whisk it in.
Sugar: I haven’t tried this recipe with a granulated sugar substitute, but I recommend either Swerve brand granulated sweetener or Lankato monkfruit granulated sweetener. You will likely have to add a bit more water by the half teaspoonful to get the dough to come together, as those sweeteners tend to be drying.