This magic gluten free custard cake creates 3 layers all by itself. The simplest ingredients make the most amazing, light and fluffy cake with a magical custard base!
What is a gluten free magic custard cake anyway?
When I first saw this spongelike custard cake, I figured it was some kind of fancy pants cake that had 3 distinct layers, each baked separately and then assembled or something. (It's not like I'm one to shy away from some fancy pants recipes, like classic yeasted gluten free croissants.)
Imagine my relief (and now I hope yours!) to see that it has the simplest, most basic ingredient list ever (butter, sugar, eggs, vanilla, flour, salt). Don't you love it when that happens?
By the way, if it looks like the most tender and moist vanilla cake you've ever tasted, buckle up. That's exactly what this magic tastes-like-custard-cake is: like our gf sponge cake, but with the richness of added butter and milk, and a creaminess you never imagined.
Why this is the best gluten free magic custard cake recipe
The magic of this custard cake is that it “separates” itself in the oven into 3 creamy, soft layers of cake. The bottom layer of the cake is the densest, most custardy layer. The middle is a fluffier style of custard. The top is the lightest, fluffiest cake, most similar to a sponge cake.
Every single layer of this rich, but light, vanilla cake melts in your mouth. It's an elegant-looking dessert that will impress your guests, your family, or just yourself!
GF custard cake ingredients
- Gluten free flour – I use Better Batter's classic gluten free flour blend here, and get consistently good results. It already contains xanthan gum, so be sure not to add more or your cake will be tough.
- Cornstarch – Adding some cornstarch to the flour blend gives a lighter, softer result. If you use a high starch gluten free flour blend, like Cup4Cup, just use more of that blend to replace the cornstarch.
- Eggs – There are 4 whole eggs in this recipe, and they must be carefully separated into yolks and whites. If you have any yolks at all in your whites, they won't whip into the peaks that you need to help this cake develop its unique baked texture.
- Lemon juice – The lemon juice acts as a stabilizing agent that helps the egg whites to hold their shape when they're beaten. In its place, you can use 1/2 teaspoon of cream of tartar, but I really prefer the bright flavor of the lemon juice.
- Sugar – Sugar is both a tenderizer and a sweetener. Don't reduce the amount in this lightly sweet cake!
- Pure vanilla extract – Vanilla is added for some depth of flavor since this is technically a “vanilla” cake.
- Butter – Unlike our gluten free sponge cake, which is very similar, this cake has butter that's been melted and cooled before being added to the batter. It adds a richness that sponge cake doesn't have, and helps the cake to form that dense, creamy bottom custard layer.
- Milk – Use something with plenty of fat here, like whole milk, to add richness, tenderness, and moisture.
How to make perfect gluten free magic cake every time
Whipping those egg whites right
I don’t mean to brag, but I happen to know the most important details when it comes to beating egg whites until they’re them light and fluffy but still stable enough to handle some manhandling as you incorporate them into a cake batter.
First, you must beat the whites until they’re stiff (but not ever dry, where they start to look a bit curdled when handled) on medium-high speed—not high! Egg whites are a lot like whipping heavy cream in that way: whip them too quickly, and you have an unstable mixture.
Second, you always want to add some sort of stabilizer to the whites as you beat them (here, I used lemon juice, but sometimes I use cream of tartar or a tiny touch of mild vinegar).
Finally, if your recipes calls for sugar, beat some sugar into the whites. It creates a glossy, stiff and more stable peak.
Choosing the right baking pan
I recommend baking this cake in an 8-inch square baking pan, one that's ideally made from cast aluminum or stainless steel since a cake that's light in color and sturdy bakes evenly and never too quickly. I don't like baking this cake in a round cake pan since the flat sides help the cake rise steadily and evenly.
Give your custard cake the space to rise
This super special cake actually smells and tastes like you’re eating custard by the forkful. To get it right, other than beating the whites just right, there’s another secret to success. You need to know what to expect as it bakes.
The cake bakes up pretty tall at a relatively low (325°F) oven temperature (it’s ready when the top is lightly golden brown and the center springs back when pressed gently), and then shrinks as it cools. That’s how you get that custard-like center.
It’s like you made a soufflé, and you intended that it would collapse a bit. Hey, I wonder if that is how this magically delicious vanilla cake got its start?!
Don't rush to slice the magic custard cake
Be sure to let the cake cool completely before slicing into it, or you may artificially deflate the cake. Plus, slice it into squares while it's still in the pan, rather than removing the whole, baked cake to a wire rack to cool. It's meant to cool in a contained environment, so it compresses a bit.
How to store your custard cake
Can I make magic custard cake in advance?
This cake is really best the day that it's made. Otherwise, you'll need to store it in the refrigerator and that can be drying.
Can I freeze leftover gf custard cake?
Yes, you can freeze this cake after it's made. Just let it cool completely, slice it into squares with a sharp knife, then lift each piece out and wrap it tightly in freezer-safe wrap. The pieces may shrink a bit in the freezer, and won't taste as fresh when you defrost them.
Custard cake substitutions
Gluten and dairy free custard cake
The dairy in this cake is in the form of melted butter and warm milk. In place of melted butter, I think you could use vegan butter (the best brands are Miyoko's Kitchen and Melt). In place of milk, try using an unsweetened plant-based milk like unsweetened Ripple brand (it tastes so good, and has tons of protein and good fat!) or almond milk. Avoid anything that's fat free.
Can you make a gluten and egg free custard cake?
This cake has 4 whole eggs, separated into yolks and whites. The yolks are emulsified with the other wet ingredients and provide richness; the whites are whipped into peaks that are folded into the batter and help create the fluffier layers. It would be quite difficult to replace the yolks, but the whites may be replaceable with whipped aquafaba (the brine from a can of chickpeas).
Custard cake variations
This is a really simple cake and there's a lot of fancy chemistry going on in the oven, but we can still change its flavor profile gently but effectively without ruining anything. Here are some suggestions:
- Almond gluten free custard cake: replace the vanilla extract with almond extract and sprinkle with very top of the cake lightly with some shaved, raw almonds;
- Coconut gluten free custard cake: replace the vanilla extract with coconut extract, and sprinkle with very top of the cake lightly with some dried coconut flakes;
- Lemon custard cake recipe: again use lemon extract in place of vanilla, use 1 tablespoon more freshly-squeezed lemon juice in place of 1 tablespoon of the milk, and add some finely grated lemon zest to the raw batter.
FAQs
Is custard gluten free?
Yes, most custard is naturally gluten free, as it's made simply with grain-free ingredients like milk, sugar, and eggs. If your custard is flavored, read the ingredients list carefully, as it may have added gluten.
Why do they call it a magic cake?
This is called a magic cake since it separates itself into relatively distinct layers, each with a unique texture and density, in the oven all by itself—like magic!
Do I have to assemble each layer when making this gf custard cake?
No! The batter for this simple gluten free custard cake is made in a few steps, preparing the recipe in multiple parts, but it goes into the oven in a single layer—and then separates itself!
Can I use coconut flour in this gluten free custard cake recipe?
No, coconut flour is a truly unique flour that absorbs massive amounts of moisture during baking and can only be used in recipes that are developed with it as an ingredient, specifically. It cannot be used as an all purpose gluten free flour, which is what this recipe calls for.
What should the custard cake batter look like?
The raw custard cake batter is very light and fluffy, and pours easily into the pan. It isn't a thin liquid, but it also isn't a thick batter that has to be painstakingly spread out in the pan either.
How do I know when a gluten free magic custard cake is done baking?
Your custard cake is done when it is lightly golden brown on top, springs back when pressed gently in the center with your finger, and jiggles in a controlled way when moved gently from side to side (like cheesecake). If it seems to move more loosely toward the center, it's not done yet.
Do I need to refrigerate this gluten free custard magic cake?
You can store this cake in the pan, with the top of the pan covered, for up to one day at room temperature. After that, individual pieces should be wrapped and refrigerated or even frozen.
Gluten free magic custard cake recipe
Magic Gluten Free Custard Cake Recipe | Vanilla Sponge with Creamy Custard
Ingredients
- ¾ cup (105 g) all purpose gluten free flour blend (I used Better Batter; click thru for appropriate blends)
- ¼ teaspoon xanthan gum omit if your blend already contains it
- 2 tablespoons (18 g) cornstarch (or try potato starch or arrowroot in its place)
- 4 (200 g (weighed out of shell)) eggs at room temperature, separated
- 1 tablespoon freshly squeezed lemon juice
- ¾ cup (150 g) granulated sugar
- 1 tablespoon pure vanilla extract
- 9 tablespoons (126 g) unsalted butter melted and cooled
- 2 cups (16 fluid ounces) warm milk (about 95°F)
- Confectioners’ sugar for dusting
Instructions
- Preheat your oven to 325°F. Grease well the bottom and sides of an 8-inch square baking dish, and set it aside. In a small bowl, place the flour, xanthan gum and cornstarch, whisk to combine well and set the bowl aside.
- In the bowl of a stand mixer fitted with the whisk attachment, or a large bowl with a handheld mixer, beat the egg whites and lemon juice on medium-high speed until frothy.
- Add about half of the granulated sugar, and continue to beat on medium-high speed until stiff, glossy (but not dry) peaks form (about 2 minutes).
If using a stand mixer.
- Transfer the egg white mixture to another bowl, set the egg whites aside and place the egg yolks, remaining sugar and vanilla in the mixer bowl.
- Beat the yolks, sugar and vanilla on medium-high speed with the paddle attachment until well-combined and pale.
If using a hand mixer.
- Set the bowl of egg whites aside. Place the egg yolks, remaining sugar and vanilla in a separate, large bowl and beat on medium-high speed until well-combined and pale.
Assemble the rest of the batter.
- No matter what mixer you're using, to the egg yolk mixture, add the melted butter, and beat to combine well.
- Add the flour mixture and the warm milk to the bowl in three parts each, beginning and ending with the flour and beating until just combined after each addition. The mixture will be thin.
- Add the beaten egg whites to the batter in three parts, whisking gently to combine after each addition until no obvious white streaks remain. The final cake batter should be light and fluffy.
- Pour the batter into the prepared pan. Place the pan in the center of the preheated oven.
- Bake until the top of the cake is lightly golden brown and springs back when pressed gently in the center (about 50 minutes). The cake will expand quite a lot in size, but will still be a bit jiggly when shaken gently back and forth.
- Remove the cake from the oven and allow to cool for at least 15 minutes in the pan before slicing into squares with a sharp knife, while the cake is still in the pan.
- The cake will shrink on all sides as it cools. Dust lightly with confectioners’ sugar before serving.
Notes
Magic Gluten Free Custard Cake Recipe | Vanilla Sponge with Creamy Custard
Ingredients
- ¾ cup (105 g) all purpose gluten free flour blend (I used Better Batter; click thru for appropriate blends)
- ¼ teaspoon xanthan gum omit if your blend already contains it
- 2 tablespoons (18 g) cornstarch (or try potato starch or arrowroot in its place)
- 4 (200 g (weighed out of shell)) eggs at room temperature, separated
- 1 tablespoon freshly squeezed lemon juice
- ¾ cup (150 g) granulated sugar
- 1 tablespoon pure vanilla extract
- 9 tablespoons (126 g) unsalted butter melted and cooled
- 2 cups (16 fluid ounces) warm milk (about 95°F)
- Confectioners’ sugar for dusting
Instructions
- Preheat your oven to 325°F. Grease well the bottom and sides of an 8-inch square baking dish, and set it aside. In a small bowl, place the flour, xanthan gum and cornstarch, whisk to combine well and set the bowl aside.
- In the bowl of a stand mixer fitted with the whisk attachment, or a large bowl with a handheld mixer, beat the egg whites and lemon juice on medium-high speed until frothy.
- Add about half of the granulated sugar, and continue to beat on medium-high speed until stiff, glossy (but not dry) peaks form (about 2 minutes).
If using a stand mixer.
- Transfer the egg white mixture to another bowl, set the egg whites aside and place the egg yolks, remaining sugar and vanilla in the mixer bowl.
- Beat the yolks, sugar and vanilla on medium-high speed with the paddle attachment until well-combined and pale.
If using a hand mixer.
- Set the bowl of egg whites aside. Place the egg yolks, remaining sugar and vanilla in a separate, large bowl and beat on medium-high speed until well-combined and pale.
Assemble the rest of the batter.
- No matter what mixer you're using, to the egg yolk mixture, add the melted butter, and beat to combine well.
- Add the flour mixture and the warm milk to the bowl in three parts each, beginning and ending with the flour and beating until just combined after each addition. The mixture will be thin.
- Add the beaten egg whites to the batter in three parts, whisking gently to combine after each addition until no obvious white streaks remain. The final cake batter should be light and fluffy.
- Pour the batter into the prepared pan. Place the pan in the center of the preheated oven.
- Bake until the top of the cake is lightly golden brown and springs back when pressed gently in the center (about 50 minutes). The cake will expand quite a lot in size, but will still be a bit jiggly when shaken gently back and forth.
- Remove the cake from the oven and allow to cool for at least 15 minutes in the pan before slicing into squares with a sharp knife, while the cake is still in the pan.
- The cake will shrink on all sides as it cools. Dust lightly with confectioners’ sugar before serving.
Lynn munroe says
Can I use vegan milk and butter, I want to try this recipe but have gluten and dairy allergy
Nicole Hunn says
Please see the section of the post titled: Custard cake substitutions; Gluten and dairy free custard cake
Belinda Hart says
This came out good. Followed the directions except for using cream of tartar and salted butter. I can’t exactly see three layers but it tastes good. It definitely could use more taste like lemon or orange since it’s a little bland. I’ll make it again using something for flavor. I don’t know why so many people had problems with it going over the pan while baking, mine was perfect. The batter is very thin until you add the egg whites which worried me at first. It was fun trying something new! Thanks for the recipe! *I used King Arthur cup for cup, monk fruit sweetener and half cream half almond milk.
Amanda L says
This is so delicious, as usual – thanks for all the hard work and for sharing with us! A question though… I had so much batter I had to use a deep pan. I was afraid to whisk the egg whites in too much and deflate them but Im thinking I probably should have whisked more? And then the layers didnt really form either. I followed the instructions and used all ingredients as instructed. Any idea why I wouldnt get layers? Is it that I didnt whisk enough at the end? Or something else? Thanks!
Nicole Hunn says
It sounds like maybe you overwhipped the egg whites, Amanda. Or perhaps your pan simply was too shallow? Mine is 2.5 inches deep, I believe.
MEG MAYO LUCAS says
I made this tonight using Better Batter, a scale, and did not substitute any ingredients. My batter ballooned over the top of my pan, reminding me very much of the Egg White Bread that is very popular in Keto baking right now. And it collapsed, just as stated, when it cooled. So much had flowed over the pan, that the final cake was not as tall as it should be. But, the part that flowed over the pan edges tasted just like traditional angel food cake. Maybe next time, I won’t whip the egg whites so much.
Nicole Hunn says
It sounds like you overwhipped the egg whites, Meg. I would also check your oven temperature with an oven thermometer, since it also sounds like it could be from a too-hot oven (and most ovens run hot). I’m afraid since you haven’t given me any other details that’s all I can offer.
MEG MAYO LUCAS says
Those two things are precisely what I thought too. I do check my oven, and it’s accurate, but maybe a lower rack position in the oven might help. Thank you!
Bobbi Siek says
Is there a sugar substitute that works for gluten free baking or cooking?
Nicole Hunn says
There’s no substitute that I can say will work in every recipe, no, Bobbi. If you’re looking for only sugar free recipes, I’d recommend a keto blog, which specializes in that.
Mairi says
Can this yummy recipe be posted to Pinterest? I save all my recipes there. 😊
Nicole Hunn says
Of course, Mairi! There’s a “pin it” button in the recipe card itself. Here’s the link.
JoAnn Billitti says
Oh my gosh, this is so yummy! I will definitely be making this over and over again!
Nicole Hunn says
So glad, JoAnn! Thanks for sharing your experience.
Barb says
can this be made dairy free
Nicole Hunn says
Please see the substitutions section of the post for suggestions on how to avoid dairy in this recipe, Barb. That section is in every recipe.
Louise M Soweski says
Hi, love your recipes…my sister is Celiac, I bake for her all the time…
Could I use pastry flour to make it for myself?
Nicole Hunn says
Hi, Louise, if you mean can you use conventional, gluten-containing pastry flour to make this recipe for yourself, I’m afraid I don’t recommend that. My gluten free recipes are designed to be made with gluten free flour blends, and the whole recipe is balanced differently. The recipe that this is adapted from is a conventional recipe, and I have it linked in the recipe notes. Maybe try her recipe?
CAROL says
#6 REMOVE THE CAKE “FROM” THE OVEN ETC. I LET YOU YOU KNOW THE WORD FROM HAD BEEN OMITTED. I DID THIS BECAUSE AS I READ OVER THE ENTIRE RECIPE ON SEVERAL OF YOU RECIPES THERE ARE SO MANY QUESTIONS FROM PEOPLE THAT ARE SO OBVIOUS THAT THEY ASK ANYWAY.
Nicole Hunn says
Thank you for pointing that out, Carol. I’ve added the word! And yes, there are often questions that are answered in the text of the post, but I’m used to people asking without having read. Answering is part of the job! 😊
Sue Carter says
Hello. I really want to try this recipe. However, I am in the Uk and can’t seem to get ‘Better Batter’s classic gluten free flour blend’. Is there an alternative I can get here? many thanks
Nicole Hunn says
Please click the link associated with that ingredient in the recipe card, Sue, and you’ll be taken to the all purpose gluten free flour blends page that discusses how to build your own comparable blend and provides comprehensive information on the subject.
Renee Kraus says
I am trying to make a Gf boston cream pie. I was thinking this would work well. just topped with chocolate ganache. any thoughts? or ideas on what to use instead?
Autumn says
Could you make this in a round cake pan for a layer cake? This looks so yummy, I think it would great for a birthday cake tonight!
Nicole Hunn says
You could definitely make it in a round cake pan, Autumn, but I’m not sure it would really work as a layer cake. It’s very light and kind of fluffy, and layering two cakes on top of each other would weigh down and compress the bottom layer quite a lot. I think it would be great as a birthday cake as is, maybe topped with some fresh whipped cream?
Dylan JS says
Made this last night. Definitely needs salt. I only had salted butter, so I used that, and even with that it was under-salted. Also, I subbed coconut milk for the cow milk, and it totally worked. (Yes, I’m one of *those* dairy-free people who still eats butter.) For next time, I want to add some more salt and also some lemon or orange zest (the citrus hints were there, but just barely) and a tad less sugar. All of that said, I think this is a very good recipe.
Suze says
Can this cake be made with your gum free flour blend?
Nicole Hunn says
I haven’t tried it, Suze, but it’s definitely worth a shot. I would still add that bit of xanthan gum to it, as listed in the ingredients.
Mare Masterson says
Nicole, I have a friend allergic to citrus. How much cream of tartar would you use to whip the egg whites instead? I cannot wait to try this one!
Anneke says
Hey Mare — not much, a half teaspoon for that many eggs should be plenty. Usually about 1/8 teaspoon for one egg white, although my mother never gives me exact info on things like this! Hope that helps. Anneke
Nicole Hunn says
Thanks for jumping in, Anneke! I’d say 1/4 teaspoon total should do it, Mare. :)
Mare Masterson says
Thanks to both of you. I will start with 1/4 teaspoon for first time and let you know how it turns out.
Carole says
Just found out I have to do Thanksgiving for 22 this year. Are you going to come out with a new stuffing recipe with enough time to practice it ??
The Grandsons are coming out this weekend , think I’ll try this cake on them.
Lauren says
MMmmm! Stuffing is the best part of the Thanksgiving spread!
Nicole Hunn says
I’ll definitely post at least one new stuffing recipe in plenty of time, Carole. Promise. :)
Lauren says
Hey! I just knew you’d bake a cake for my birthday. Thanks! :D It looks wonderful!
Guest says
Hey! I just knew you’d bake a cake for my birthday. Thanks! :D I
Silver says
This reminds me of 3-Layer Cornbread, a recipe I’ve been meaning to convert to GF myself. Mmmmmmm, this looks wonderful.
tailorjoan says
Can this be made dairy free using earth balance butter and coconut milk?
Nicole Hunn says
I haven’t tried, but I generally prefer Spectrum nonhydrogenated vegetable shortening, not Earth Balance, as a butter sub. Maybe try the butter-flavored kind. For the milk, I’d go with almond milk.
Jennifer S. says
Um, yum. That is all that needs to be said.
Lucy says
You shy away from a fancypants cake? Is there such a thing!?
I might but never the queen of GF baking :)
This does look yummy, many thanks Nicole :)
Nicole Hunn says
No, no Lucy, I definitely don’t shy away from fancypants recipes, but it’s always nice when something simply looks fancypants and is actually quite simple. :)