Gluten Free Cinnamon Swirl Bread

Nothing compares to the flavor and aroma of freshly baked gluten free cinnamon swirl bread coming out of your oven. It even keeps and reheats well!

If you like cinnamon rolls, you’re going to love the taste and smell of fresh gluten free cinnamon swirl bread baking in your house. Unlike most gluten free yeast bread recipes, this dough rises twice, giving it more flavor and better texture. Add the cinnamon sugar filling, and you’re halfway to heaven.

This bread dough has plenty of enrichments to make it soft and tender, but it’s most certainly yeast bread—not cake. In fact, almost all of the sugar is in the filling, not in the bread itself. 

How does this compare to quickbread?

We already have a recipe for gluten free cinnamon swirl quick bread, and it’s amazing for a special breakfast or brunch with a big cup of coffee. ☕️ Most quickbreads are, basically, cake and that recipe is no exception. 

It tastes like a dressed up coffee cake, complete with a simple sugary drizzle. The only real difference is that you bake it in a loaf pan and slice it by the cross-section. It’s made without any yeast, and has a really nice open crumb.

This recipe for cinnamon swirl bread is a yeast bread, more like our recipe for gluten free white sandwich bread than any quickbread could ever be. The cinnamon swirl running through the center of the bread makes it less appropriate for sandwich-making, but it’s not out of the question.

In fact, years ago, there were a few times that I packed my children’s lunches on cinnamon swirl bread. They still speak longingly about how they would take out the sandwich filling and eat it separately, then eat around the cinnamon-sugar filling, saving it for last.

How to make this cinnamon swirl yeast bread

Using a stand mixer

The only way that I know how to make this yeast bread dough is by using the paddle attachment of a stand mixer. All of my instructions will assume that you’re using a stand mixer, which I find essential.

You may be able to use a food processor to make the dough, especially if you have a plastic attachment, rather than the metal blade. If you try that method, please let us know how it goes!

All you do, essentially, is dump the ingredients, in the order listed in the recipe, into the bowl, and let the mixer process it fully. It couldn’t be easier!

What is the bread dough like?

Like our white sandwich bread recipe and all of our original-style gluten free yeast bread recipes, this is a batter-style bread recipe. That means that the dough is very soft and wet, and has the consistency more of cookie dough than what you might expect from conventional yeast bread dough.

However, unlike most batter-style gluten free yeast bread recipes, this bread dough is allowed to rise twice. The first rise is in a tightly-sealed container, in the refrigerator. Yeast will grow in a refrigerator, just more slowly. 

Placing the dough in the refrigerator for its first rise allows the dough to develop some light yeast flavor and gives the dough some more time to absorb moisture. That way, the dough is fully hydrated but easier to shape. 

You’ll notice that this recipe calls for one of my recommended all purpose gluten free flour blends, but not our gluten free bread flour, made with whey protein isolate and Expandex modified tapioca starch.

Recipes made with the bread flour blend from GFOAS Bakes Bread behave much more like conventional yeast bread, but those ingredients can be harder to source. This a bread recipe for all—but it won’t be exactly like it would if it were made with our bread flour blend. For that type of bread, try one of these recipes.

Shaping the dough

To shape the dough, all that is necessary is to knead the risen dough lightly on a very lightly floured surface, sprinkling it lightly with more flour in any spots that are very wet. Then, roll it into a rectangle and cover the rectangle with a thin layer of softened butter. 

Then, sprinkle the cinnamon sugar filling on top and press it down to help it adhere to the dough. Roll the dough tightly, tucking the ends under and squeezing lightly as you go.

The final rise

With the seam side down, lift the dough into a loaf pan, cover it with oiled plastic wrap, and set the pan in a warm, draft-free spot to allow it to rise. It won’t double in size, as it might in the refrigerator, but should be about 150% of its original size, as it was shaped in the loaf pan. 

Keep in mind that yeast will double and dough will rise on its own timetable. If your environment is on the cooler side, it will take longer to rise. If it’s warmer, it will rise more quickly.

Overproofing, where the dough rises too much, is not caused by too much time. It’s caused by too much rise. If your dough needs more time, don’t argue! Respect its process. :)

Slash and bake

Once the dough has risen, uncover it and slash it down the center with a lame or sharp knife, which will allow the dough to split where you want it to during baking. Otherwise, it will decide where to split, and it might not be very pretty. 

Brush the top of the risen and slashed dough with an egg wash, and bake. We use a relatively low oven (325°F) so that the bread can bake all the way to the center and the bottom without burning. After 45 minutes of baking, we’ll transfer the bread out of the pan and onto a baking sheet for its final minutes in the oven. That will allow the oven air to circulate around the sides of the dough. Then, cool and slice. 

Ingredients and substitutions

Buttermilk powder: I really like using buttermilk powder in baking, since I find that it adds richness and tenderness to baked goods. The brand I use is Saco. It comes in a little round paper container with a lid and can be found in the baking section of most grocery stores, at least in my part of the U.S. 

If you can’t find buttermilk powder, you can use nonfat dry milk powder in its place. It doesn’t add as much richness, but the recipe will still work. 

Dairy-free: If you need to make this recipe dairy-free, you’ll have to replace the buttermilk powder in the dough, and the butter in both the dough and the filling. In place of the buttermilk powder, you can try using powdered coconut milk.

In place of the butter in the bread dough, try using Earth Balance buttery sticks or virgin coconut oil. In place of the butter in the filling, you will need to use something that doesn’t have too much moisture or the filling will leak a ton. Try using virgin coconut oil or Spectrum nonhydrogenated vegetable shortening.

Egg-free: There are two egg whites in the bread dough recipe. I haven’t tried replacing them, and I’m afraid I’m really not sure what, if anything, would work in their place. In the past I’ve suggested trying aquafaba (the brine from a can of chickpeas), but readers have reported poor results overall. The egg in the egg wash can easily be replaced with cream alone.

Tapioca starch/flour: The addition of tapioca starch/flour to the bread dough helps make it stretchy and tender. In its place, you can try using another starch, or just more all purpose gluten free flour, but neither will give the same results.