Gluten free cowboy cookies are chewy and hearty, with just the right amount of chocolate chips in a big, generous cookie packed with oats and coconut chips.
The cowboy cookies origin story
I’m no cowboy, and frankly I was always kind of neutral about Laura Bush, but these are some seriously good cookies. I don’t think she “invented” cowboy cookies. Clearly, Tipper Gore didn’t stand a chance with her gingersnap cookies.
I love snappy, spicy gingersnaps, but if I’m entering a contest I’m not showing up with that. Even just visually, a cookie with mix-ins beats a straight-up cutout cookie with no frosting, no nothing, any day of the week.
Let’s ignore that, as recently as election year 2000, Family Circle Magazine held a cookie bake-off between the presidential candidates’ wives, Tipper Gore and Laura Bush. That certain wifely stereotype, like that’s all that they’re good for, has thankfully been upended (right?).
I’m just in it for the cookies anyway. My gluten free cowboy cookies are chewy and hearty (oats!), with just the right amount of chocolate chips in a big, generous gluten free chocolate chip cookie.
A nubby, hearty cookie
My version of gluten free cowboy cookies, seen in these photos and the how-to video, don’t spread much, if at all, during baking. I cut back on the butter called for in the original recipe (or at least Laura Bush’s version of it).
I wanted a thick cookie that was crispy on the outside, chewy on the inside. So shape them before baking in the manner in which you’d like them to turn out after baking.
This is not the type of cookie you’re going to eat when it’s gooey, as it has a crisp outside when it cools. After baking and before they’re cool, the cookies will be fragile. After they’re mostly cool, their crisp and nubby texture outside makes them very stable.
What the raw cookie dough is like
This cookie dough doesn’t happen to be especially sticky, even though the cookies are chewy inside. Often, the chewiest cookies begin with the stickiest cookie dough.
These cookies are made in one bowl, using what’s called the “reverse cream” method, where the wet ingredients are mixed into the dry. This way we don’t add much air to the cookie dough, which preserves the hearty, chewy flavor.
There’s enough butter and eggs to moisten all of the dry ingredients, but you may find that some of the most dry ingredients seem to resist combining. Just keep pressing the underside of the bowl of the spoon or spatula you are using for mixing into the wet ingredients so they absorb the flour.
Mix the dough with a spoon for as long as you can before switching to using clean, dry hands to knead the dough together. If you touch the dough with your hands too soon, too many wet ingredients will stick to your fingers.
I don’t recommend using a handheld mixer, since beaters will aerate the dough too much. But you can use a stand mixer fitted with the paddle attachment and make quick work of making the dough.
Ingredients and substitutions
In place of the butter in this recipe, I recommend trying Melt or Miyoko’s Kitchen brand vegan butter. I don’t recommend Earth Balance buttery sticks, as they contain too much moisture and your cookies will spread too much and potentially burn before they’re nicely browned.
If you’re dairy-free, be careful about your chocolate chips. There are plenty of gluten free varieties of semi sweet chocolate chips. You could use any other sort of chip you like for a different flavor profile.
There are two eggs in this recipe. Try replacing each of them with a “chia egg” (1 tablespoon ground white chia seeds + 1 tablespoon lukewarm water, mixed and allowed to gel).
Purity protocol gluten free oats are, indeed, safely gluten free. If you can’t find those sort of oats, or you simply won’t eat them, you can try using beaten rice in their place (for more detail on oat substitutions in baking <—click over).
If you think you don’t care for coconut, you might not be familiar with the good type of coconut (just an idea). are you thinking of the bagged, shredded sweetened coconut?
If you’ve never tried the wide, flat coconut flakes that are sometimes called coconut chips, I submit that you’re selling coconut short. If you want to replace it here, though, maybe try an equal amount, by weight, of chopped nuts.
The coconut chips are adding flavor and texture, but not really entering into the chemical reaction in any meaningful way. So experiment away!