Fortune Cookies
33

See? {picture below} I can predict the future. I know. If you didn’t know better, you’d think I were Nostradamus. Tell me about it … No. Really. Go on. Tell … more »

Gluten Free Fortune CookiesSee? {picture below} I can predict the future. I know. If you didn’t know better, you’d think I were Nostradamus. Tell me about it … No. Really. Go on. Tell me about it.Gluten Free Fortune Cookies

If you circle the web, looking for Fortune Cookie recipes, you’ll find tons of directions and comments and recipes and it can sound kind of scary: You have to work super speedy quick or they’ll be stiff before you get started shaping them. If the batter is too thick, they will just be like cake. If it is too thin, they’ll stick to the baking sheet liner. Use butter. Don’t use butter.

Here’s what I say: Blah blah blah bladdy blah. Blah.

I was really intimidated when I first decided to make these. I had been led to believe that, not only were they tricky under the best of circumstances, but I was making my own gluten-free recipe. Oh, the humanity! Horror!

Oh, bother.

I swear, nothing sucks the fun right out of baking more than intimidation. And it’s really starting to get on my nerves, all this discouragement. So I’m here to tell you, rest assured. These are easy peasy. Most things, if you do them right, are easy peasy. Trying to force a square peg into a round hole, that’s not easy. Hell, it’s not even possible. But baking with a good all-purpose gluten-free flour makes all things gluten-free possible.

So I predict … that you will be successful making these fortune cookies unless you use a bean flour blend. Bean flour blend people, we have to talk.

There are those of you, and you know who you are, who use bean flour blends successfully. You are aware that these blends are not genuine “all-purpose gluten-free flours” {even if you’re not quite willing to admit it}, and you have your work-arounds. You should live and be well, baking your way from Fortune Cookies to Tiramisu.

The rest of us — step away from the bean flour.

I understand that there is at least one readily available, well-priced brand of bean flour. I know that it’s significantly more nutritious than rice-based flours.

I don’t care.

It smells bad, and {and this bit is important, so please put on your listening ears} … BEAN FLOURS DO NOT BEHAVE THE SAME. They are stickier and simply not as durable as rice-based flour blends. You will not be successful in these recipes. Many of you send me emails, asking why this or that recipe didn’t work for you. You’re understandably frustrated. 99% of the time, you’re using a bean flour blend. You don’t tell me that straight away, because you don’t know that it’s a problem. But it’s a problem. A biggie.

Look, I used to use a bean flour, too. I started out with Bette Hagman’s “Four Flour Bean Mix.” BUT THAT WAS OVER SIX YEARS AGO! There was nothing else out there. I had no choices. I thought I had died and gone to heaven when I found a bean flour blend in my local, mainstream supermarket. Eureka! But today, there are upwards of 15 companies that make all-purpose gluten-free flour blends. You don’t have to use Better Batter like I do. This is not a cult of personality. I’m not the GF Flour Police. It’s a Free Country! Use Jules, use Gluten-free Pantry, use Tom Sawyer {good if you have a potato allergy, since it is the only one I know of that is sans potato of any sort}. You get the idea.

With that in mind, let’s make some Fortune Cookies. They’re tender yet crispy, and I could eat, like, a million of them at once because they’re so deliciously subtle. And you could totally make some for your spouse and add some naughty fortunes to them and stuff. Just be sure not to give the naughty ones to your kids. ‘Cause you’d scar them for life. Don’t say I didn’t warn you.

4.8 from 4 reviews

Fortune Cookies
By: 
Recipe type: Dessert
Prep time: 
Cook time: 
Total time: 

Serves: 30 to 35
 

Gluten-free fortune cookies
Ingredients
  • 3 extra-large egg whites
  • ¾ cup sugar
  • 6 tablespoons unsalted butter, melted and cooled
  • 1 teaspoon pure almond extract
  • 1 cup all-purpose gluten free flour (I use Better Batter)
  • ½ teaspoon xanthan gum (omit if using Better Batter)
  • Pinch kosher salt
  • ½ cup (8 tablespoons) water, plus more if necessary

Instructions
  1. Preheat your oven to 375 degrees Fahrenheit. Line a rimmed baking sheet with either a Silpat (best case) or parchment paper, and set it aside.
  2. With an electric beater (or your stand mixer with the whisk attachment), whisk the egg whites and sugar on high until foamy (not stiff), about 2 minutes. Add the butter, almond extract, flour, xanthan gum, salt, and water, one at a time, blending well on low speed after each addition. The batter should be thin (ideally, thinner than pancake batter). Gluten-free flours thicken upon standing, so as you work, don’t be afraid to add more water by the tablespoon if necessary to thin it out.
  3. On the prepared baking sheet, spoon about ½ tablespoon of batter in circles, about 3 at a time (I was able to shape them successfully with 4 at a time on a baking sheet, but no more). Thin the circles with the back of a spoon as evenly as you can, until the circles are about 2 inches in diameter. Try not to make the edges thinner than the middle, or the edges will cook too quickly.
  4. Place the baking sheet in the center of the preheated oven and bake for about 5 minutes, until the edges of the cookies have just begun to brown. Remove the baking sheet from the oven, allow to cool for less than a minute, and carefully release the cookies with a thin spatula, starting at the edges and working your way in.
  5. Place a fortune in the center of each cookie (optional). Fold each cookie in half around the (optional) fortune, and then fold the ends of the half together into a horseshoe shape, pressing to secure the edges together. For a more authentic shaped cookie, holding onto the edges, press down on the folded end to round it a bit. Place the shaped cookies in a mini muffin tin or egg carton until firm (a few minutes).
  6. Repeat with the remaining batter. Some will turn out perfectly, and you’ll briefly entertain opening a Chinese restaurant just so you can serve them. Some of them won’t turn out at all, and you’ll be sure to eat them when nobody is looking so as to avoid ruining your reputation. It all evens out in the end.
  7. Serve (the best ones) the same day, if possible. They tend to get stale rather quickly. If you would like to serve them a day later, consider crisping them in a relatively cool oven (about 250 degrees) before serving, being mindful of the combustible paper fortunes inside.

 

What sort of all-purpose gluten-free flour do you use? Do you make your own? Do you use a commercial blend? How did you decide on it, and do you ever think of changing? I’ll go first — I learned about Better Batter from you all — readers on this site! Thank you kindly. Now you — what’s your blend, honey?

Love you. Mean it.
xoxo Nicole

  • http://www.sweetjaynehandmade.wordpress.com Jayne Hickey

    I have the basic mix; brown rice flour, potato starch and tapioca starch – always on hand, mixed up in a mason jar in the fridge. But I bought a big bag of Pamela’s GF Bread Mix & Flour Blend and I’ve enjoyed using that as an all-purpose flour. I like the multi-grain(ness) of it; sorghum flour and millet flour in there as well. I had never heard of Better Batter until you and I have to say, I’m looking forward to trying it. Just sent in my application for the reduced price, this mama is single and on a bare-bones budget!
    In other news, your cookbook finally arrived from Barnes & Noble – they had a wee bit of a shipping delay, but it is here now and I am so happy! Yum, yum, and yum! I can’t wait to strap on my apron and get to mixin’!
    And as far as bean flour mixes go….pffft – yeah, that ‘s the sound you read. Seriously, why use a bean flour blend in your baking, how many people really make whole wheat chocolate chip cookies? When you want sweets, you want sweets, white flour and all. There’s a time and a place for whole grain nutrition, I choose to eat my beans in my main course, not in my desserts and other baking delights! My .02, hope you enjoyed it!
    Thanks for the fortune cookie recipe, I predict that will be a fun thing to make for the kids and their friends!

    • Nicole

      Hi, Jayne,
      It’s always great to hear from you. I love that Naomi Poe of Better Batter is such a benevolent entrepreneur that she has that reduced price application. She is really wonderful. I hope that works out for you. I know she and her team often work hard with people to find a price that they can afford. In the meantime, I’m glad you have your own mix that’s working for you. Be careful with Pamela’s Bread mix — it isn’t an all-purpose flour. It has baking powder and baking soda in the ingredients, so it will not perform like all purpose flour. It is great for pizza crust and bread when you follow her directions, but it is not intended for everything. You probably already know that, but just in case, I figured I’d mention it.
      So funny about the bean flour. Of course I enjoyed your $.02! I prefer to keep beans in my main dish as well. And the thing is — I LOVE beans. Just not in my cakes and breads. I have heard that they are going to try to start “enriching” gluten-free products, but no amount of enrichment will make a refined grain a whole grain. I would rather make up for it with more fruits and vegetables and other whole foods. And you’re so right about whole wheat flour. Nobody really bakes with that. It doesn’t perform the same as white flour. That’s why white flour is called “all-purpose flour”!
      I hope you enjoy the fortune cookies. Remember, no naughty bits for the kids. :)
      xoxo
      Nicole

  • Anneke

    Hey Nicole! I am using my 25 lb bag of Better Batter right now, and I also like Jules. My bread (sourdough) seems to rise better with the Jules than it has been with the BB flour, but our weather is a little weird right now, so that may be part of it. I plan to buy another bag of Jules to do a comparison. Bean flour is dreadful, I cannot stand the smell or taste, and it does not agree with all of the people in my family. I think part of some people not noticing or caring about the taste may be related to how many homemade baked goods they had as a child. My mother made everything from scratch, including 8 loaves of bread a week, but my husband’s mother barely boiled spaghetti! While the bean flour doesn’t agree with him, he doesn’t really taste a difference.
    I am planning to fit in a batch of lemon bars today, but probably not fortune cookies. They sound really fun, though, so they are on the list. My real project for today is to organize my recipes and get a binder going of all the ones I have printed off the blog — there is a big pile! Hope you have a great day! Anneke

    • Nicole

      Hi, Anneke,
      That’s an interesting point, about people’s sensitivity to different flours being related to how much freshly baked goods they ate as children. I think that, also, some people are super tasters. I remember reading about this ages and ages ago. Think of how some people love extra spicy foods (e.g., my husband), and others (e.g., me) think even things considered relatively ‘mild’ are, in fact, pretty spicy. I’m a super taster, for sure. I have a really keen sense of smell. I think that’s part of it, too. How is your husband’s sense of smell? How is he with spicy foods? I wonder if that holds up…
      Interesting that you find that your bread rises better with Jules’ flour. I wonder if it’s because it contains “Expandex.” Kinda like “Spanx” for your bread to look its best. :)
      By the way, the lemon bars are even better the next day!
      xoxo
      Nicole

  • Linda

    These look great, Nicole – will have to try them sometime. I opted for making your scones instead – got lucky and found giant blueberries (like 1-inch size!). The funny thing was I noticed that in your recipe in your cookbook you forgot to mention folding in the berries & even though I made note of it while reading the recipe, I still forgot to add them myself! :) So since my dough was already in a rectangle, I just gently pushed the berries in. It’s all good! And they’re almost all gone! :) The fortune cookies look like a lot of fun, too!

    • Nicole

      Hi, Linda,
      I know! I’m so sorry about the berry scone recipe! It’s an editing mistake, and will be corrected in subsequent printings (unfortunately, the first printing was rather large, so it will take us a bit to work through it). I wish there were some way for me to contact everyone who bought the cookbook in this first printing, to tell them about it. I thought about doing a blog post about it, but it would get buried in the blog in no time, so it wouldn’t reach everyone. I’m so glad that you pressed your berries in at the end. Honestly, that’s a pretty good way to do it anyway. Those blueberries you found sound amazing. I love blueberry season! I tried, unsuccessfully, to plant my own blueberry bush last year.
      Thanks for the post, and again, I apologize for the blueberry omission in the book!
      xoxo
      Nicole

  • Linda

    By the way, I recently bought the 25-lb Better Batter flour and was wondering what you and/or anyone else uses to store it in. Another thing that had slipped my mind when I ordered it . . . I was envisioning that pretty box arriving – like five of them – ha-ha! Instead, well, you know what came instead! :) I think the flour works the same as Jules’ but the price is better – and thanks to your mention of their sale w/free shipping at the end of May – 25 lbs for $55 was super!

    • Nicole

      Hi, Linda,
      I’m so glad you received your Better Batter shipment – and at such a great price! I love having tons of that around. I have a bunch of these containers, and the 25 lbs. fit nicely into 3 of them, total: http://bit.ly/kjaB1Z. Each container has a 29-cup capacity, to give you an idea of what sort of storage would work well for you. I hope that’s helpful! Happy baking!
      xoxo
      Nicole

      • Linda

        Oh thanks for your quick reply! That’s exactly what I was thinking of finding. I think having so much flour in the house makes me want to try out ALL your great recipes. :) Going to try your cornmeal dinner rolls to go with a pot of chili tonight. It’s raining cats and dogs here in CT today! If you’re ever promoting your book in your neighbor state, I may just get a chance to meet ya! Take care, Linda :)

        • Nicole

          Hi, Linda,
          It was pouring here earlier today, too, but now it’s not raining. I think it will again, though. I’m glad you’re going to try the rolls. Let me know how it goes!
          xoxo
          Nicole

          • Linda

            Hi Nicole,
            The cornmeal dinner rolls came out perfect! So soft and so delicious warm – went perfect with the chili. My sons thought they’d even be good for strawberry shortcake, so we save a few to try that tomorrow. I made 8 hamburg buns and froze those for future use and 15 dinner rolls. My husband thought they tasted better than crescent dinner rolls (pre-GF days). :) I love your instructions after adding the cornmeal and saying to ‘beat the living daylights out of it’ – made me laugh – love your sense of humor! Thx again for another keeper recipe. xo Linda
            THAT’S AWESOME, LINDA! THAT SOUNDS LIKE A PERFECT MEAL FOR A STORMY DAY. WHEN YOU YOU DEFROST THE ROLLS AND BUNS, DRIZZLE THEM WITH A LITTLE BIT OF WATER AND STICK THEM IN THE MICROWAVE FOR A FEW SECONDS BEFORE SLICING AND SERVING. THEY’LL BE GOOD AS NEW. xoxo Nicole

  • Joleen Barrett

    HI! I am really confused about the bean flour! I have one of the recipes that you listed on your site – Tom’s Bread, which my kids now want as their regular bread. It uses Chickpea (Garbanzo Bean) Flour. Is there a substitute I should use in its place?

    • Nicole

      Hi, Joleen,
      That isn’t my recipe (the Tom’s Bread). If you are going to make that recipe, I would do it as-is. I have no idea why it works the way it does, so I have never wanted to mess with it. I haven’t made that bread in many years, and I honestly don’t even know if it smells bad before it’s baked or not! It is usually the garbanzo flour that smells bad, so it likely does. Back when I made that, I had no all-purpose gluten-free flour that didn’t contain beans. In my book, I have a White Sandwich Bread recipe that uses an all purpose gluten free flour. If you have the book, try that. Otherwise, try Tom’s, and good luck!
      xoxo
      Nicole

  • Shalini Lynch

    I’m in the middle of making a batch of these and they are DELICIOUS. I used vanilla extra instead of almond, though as that’s what I had on hand. I am having trouble with the texture though….they either remain soft inside the edges or they break when I fold them. Also if they start getting color all over, they break. Is this because I’m not folding them fast enough, or were my egg whites not stiff enough? And are “foamy” egg whites before the soft peak stage? I don’t have a lot of experience whipping egg whites.

    • Nicole

      Hi, Shalini,
      I think it’s just a matter of not baking them too long. As you say, you don’t want them to get browned all over, or they will be brittle. And you don’t want to spread them too thin, or they will brown in an instant. Spread the batter a wee bit thicker toward the edges so they bake a bit slower there. And they won’t be crisp when you fold them. They will crisp after you have folded them, and as they cool. You didn’t do anything wrong with the foamy egg whites. Foamy is just what you think it is. No peaks. Just sudsy. Anyway, they’re not that temperamental that that would cause you a problem. You’ll get the technique down. Don’t worry. It’s like crepes and blintzes. The first few are usually duds, and then you get the hang of it. You’re doing fine… Enjoy!
      xoxo Nicole

  • Shalini Lynch

    As far as flour blends go, our favorite to date is Gluten Free Classical Blend. Sometimes we mix our own (I purchase the components at Whole Foods) and sometimes I purchase the blend (can only be purchased online from Authentic Foods). I recently bought Better Batter for the first time and we like it for cookies and doughs. For whatever reason, my family seems to prefer muffins and cakes with the other. We haven’t done a direct taste comparison……I’m basing this on how many days the kids will eat a particular batch after it’s baked. The textures do change over time (measured in days) and some textures seem to be preferred over others. I would say that 80% of our flour use is for pancakes and waffles and we have never added xanthum gum to these batters, so we’ve just stuck with the old standby for these. In the past we’ve also used Bette Hagman’s Featherlight mix which is good, but things come out a little “bouncy” with it. One of our local food co-ops teaches in their baking class how to modify the proportions of this mix so the product is less “bouncy”.

    • Nicole

      Hi, Shalini,
      All those mixes sound like a lot of work. I’m way too lazy for that! I am sure that some blends work better than others for certain recipes (like less xanthan gum would be good for quickbreads, and more for yeast breads), but I’m from the good-enough-is-good-enough camp. I started off, nearly 7 years ago by now, making different Bette Hagman blends for everything, but it got old really, really quick. If you’re still willing to stick it out, though, more power to you! That’s great that you have food co-op, and that they give gluten-free baking classes. Wow!
      xoxo Nicole

  • Shalini Lynch

    Nicole, thanks for the tips!!! I’m still baking :) :) Most of the cookies are coming out white with brown edges. I’m going to try spreading them differently as you suggest. They are getting eaten as soon as (or even before…..) they cool so I have no cookies left to store. Did I mention that my family hasn’t eaten dinner yet? They just keep jumping up every time they hear the oven time go off and running to fold them. Do you think if I stick a piece of broccoli inside one they would notice?

    • Nicole

      Hi, Shalini,
      Sounds like you have some ready and willing assistants. With friends like that, you could probably bake a whole bunch at once!
      And, no, I think a stalk of broccoli would be virtually undetectable in there. Maybe first try a “You will eat broccoli” fortune, the move up to the actual stalk, though? Just a suggestion. :)
      xoxo Nicole

  • Shalini Lynch

    Nicole, actually I’m too lazy for multiple mixes too. I was just giving the history of what we’ve tried. Waaaay TMI, I know. You can tell I just finished coaching a child who doesn’t enjoy remembering details through a year of 4th grade tests. But I did happen to have two different mixes in my house at that same time, so we have been going back and forth through them for a while. Because once I have a supply of anything, it has to get used up!! And I rarely bake more than once a week so it can take a while. For the record, I refuse to use bean flour in any form for any purpose.

    • Nicole

      Hi, Shalini,
      It’s funny how a description of what someone has done over time can make things seem condensed and so very, very busy. It sounded like you were making the perfect mix every time, for just the right recipe. I thought, more power to you! For the record, I’m so glad you refuse to use bean flour!
      xoxo
      Nicole

  • Pingback: Weekly Gluten-Free Roundup – June 26, 2011 « Celiac Kitchen Witch

  • Jen

    These look yummy! Just sayin’ :)

    I use Silvana Nardone’s gf flour mix from Cooking for Isaiah – I can mix it myself very easily, yet I’ve found it works well in just about every recipe. I have the flexibility of making pretty much whatever I want, but I don’t have to worry about my flour mix being out of stock at my local store (a common problem, since some of our local stores tend to “forget” to order the mixes that sell out quickly. Go figure.).

    Working my way through your cookbook and having a blast doing so!

    • Nicole

      Hi, Jen,
      Sounds like you’ve got a good system going for your all-purpose GF flour. That’s really all that matters – that you have something that you can count on to perform well for you. About your local stores ‘forgetting’ to keep up with ordering mixes that sell – what a strange business practice. I would think they’d want to be stocked up on that stuff.
      I’m so glad you’re enjoying the cookbook. Keep reading!
      xoxo Nicole

  • Pingback: Gluten-free Ice Cream Cones

  • Kat

    Ok the jig is up-I know your secret: You are a gluten-free cookie baking space alien who somehow lost all of your home planet’s cookie recipes -probably blew out your oven on plant Whatyamajiggy and got sucked through a space vortex thereby disrupting the space/time continuem [*see Star Trek] and ended up here, unable to digest wheat –but ya gotta have your cookies or you’ll die- So now, you’re reading our minds to get our favorite recipes —which by the way is fine by me….I’m just saying: every time I read your bliggity blog you’re reinventing a cookie I LOVE (this time it’s fortune cookies) that btw, I was just thinking of the other day, while wondering if you’d re vamped it sans gluten yet?” then bada bing bada boom -there you go -doing exactly what I’ve been thinking. Ergo: telepathic Gluten-free cookie baking space alien. I rest my case and take me to your leader. PS. Ok now I’m thinking about something really yummy and gooey (maybe with sprinkles…) I’ll bet (hope) I’ll be printing the GF recipe for it, from your site soon :)

    Your secret’s safe with me.
    Nanu nanu
    Kat
    PS. I DO like my butt and thighs curvier -no really

    • Nicole

      Keep it on the down-low, would ya, Kat? The ecretsay isn’t afesay if we illspay it. ;)
      What is it that’s yummy and gooey with sprinkles that you would like to be printing? I like yummy and gooey and sprinkley and printy. Tell! What is it?
      Nanu nanu. Come in Orson …
      ;) Nicole

  • Kat

    yummy gooey sprinkly I’d like to have:
    Graham crackers (for s’morage)
    AND
    an eclair
    AND
    a raspberry filled doughnut
    AND /OR
    A custard filled doughnut with chocolate frosting…Pretty PLEASE.

    I live in Seattle equidistant to both downtown Top Pot Doughnuts -they knew me so well at both places, that when I left my bank card at one spot but ordered my afternoon coffee and doughnut from the other spot, ‘Shop A’ called ‘Shop B’ asking “Is Kat’s card up there? well ring here up for an Americano and a Pink Feather boa ( cake doughnut w/ pink icing and shredded coconut).
    But Gluten gets me in the joints -bad- so no more doughnuts or edible feather boas or gooey creamy goodness on a rainy afternoon w/ coffee …sure wish I knew someone who was a GF baking Wizard :(

    • Nicole

      Hi, Kat,
      There is a recipe for Graham Crackers in my cookbook!
      There is also a recipe for choux pastry, which forms the basis for eclairs. But the filled doughnuts — nothing on the blog or in my book for that just yet, but more and more requests. So your wish will for sure come true … :)
      xoxo Nicole

  • Kat

    yours is my next cookbook purchase! (for real!!) I just discovered you and while I do love other GF blogs and really appreciate all every GF revolutionary has contributed to the cause, I really think you’ve cracked the code not just financially but also for straight up great eats….I knew when I made your pancakes, this was not ersatz cooking- it’s the real deal only w/ different flour. btw try making a ‘hootenany’ pancake (google it) with your pancake recipe and if you eat meat, crumble up some really good maple bacon into it —but don’t say I didn’t warn you!

    Thanks so much for your hard work, I can’t wait to see what you’re cooking up next -and if I get a minute to work on some doughnuts I’ll be sure to share my findings :)
    Kat

    • Nicole

      Hi, Kat,
      First of all, I consider bacon a staple. I have bacon fat in my refrigerator waiting to be baked into something. Not for nothin’. ;)
      Thank you so much for the kind words. You really hit the nail on the head — the goal is real cooking, just with different flour. Normal. Thank you for getting it! ;)
      I hope you’ll keep reading.
      xoxo Nicole

This recipe was brought to you by Nicole Hunn of Gluten-Free on a Shoestring: http://glutenfreeonashoestring.com/fortune-cookies/
Scroll to top of page